Skip to content
  • Home
  • The why
  • Contact me
clear

Catching the Curveball

The art of dealing with the unexpected

the art of dealing with the unexpected

The art of Negotiation
In:PositiveReality

The art of Negotiation

June 20, 2018

Have you ever watched a child “negotiate” with their parents? The child takes a position on what they want, then they begin the nagging campaign, ready with every reason under the sun on why they should get what they want and then they just don’t move on that position until their parent finally gives in.

This is called positional bargaining and while you might think that adults don’t behave that way, sadly in my world as a contested estates lawyer, I see it happen all too often!

I think people have a perception from watching TV shows that the way to negotiate is to start at point well above their “bottom line” with the expectation that the settlement will end somewhere in the middle. The problems with this approach are that:

  • the settlement becomes far more about a sum of money or things (rather than about what the sum of money or the things might mean to each person),
  • the negotiation process itself can take months at significant legal cost (as lengthy “positional” emails and letters are exchanged by well-meaning lawyers) and
  • the process can be counter-productive because playing this kind of “negotiation game” can become frustrating quickly, particularly when the offers first exchanged are usually ridiculous and unattainable.

Worse still, this type of approach can potentially derail a negotiation and can mean that parties approach any subsequent court-required mediation jaded and unwilling to attempt the process genuinely. In my experience this negotiation style often leaves both parties dissatisfied and can mean that parties re-neg on agreements made in pressured mediations.

Dividing up an Orange without cutting it in half

In my experience the most successful negotiations happen when all parties are committed to an interest-based negotiation style. All this means is that the parties try to reach compromise based on proposals that best meet the parties’ underlying goals and needs. This style of negotiation aims for mutual gains. It is about trying to find ways to give each party more of what they value, rather than engaging in a win-lose negotiation that can mean one party ultimately caves in just to avoid further conflict.

One of the simplest ways to explain interest-based negotiation is a simple illustration first used in the book “Getting to Yes – negotiating an agreement without giving-in” (by Roger Fisher and William Ury). Below is a story based on that illustration, that I often use to explain this concept to my clients who are facing conflict in their own family over an inheritance:

Imagine there are two sisters fighting over one orange. Both want the whole orange and the argument escalates before mum steps in. In an effort to stop the fighting and to be fair to both children she grabs the orange and cuts it straight down the middle to give each child an equal half.

But the whinging she was trying to put a stop to continues and escalates! Why?

Little Emily explains that she needed the whole orange to squeeze out enough juice to complete her orange cake for the school baking competition, and little Lucy wails that she needed the whole orange because her class was having a competition to see who could peel the longest orange rind off in one continuous spiral!

If only the girls had spoken to each other to explain what they wanted. If only mum had stopped to ask both girls what it is they needed out of the orange. Then both of their needs could have been met. Lucy could have painstakingly peeled off the orange rind and Emily could have then had the fruit to juice for her cake.

While it is a simplistic story, it does illustrate how a win-win solution might have been reached. It is why it is so important for clients to come to an understanding about what it is they need out of the proverbial orange and to think hard about what it is their family members might need.

It is also important to realise that people have different perceptions about what is a “fair” or “equal” split. It has been said that:

fairness like beauty is in the eye of the beholder

What seems fair to you, might be quite different from what another person thinks is fair (and perhaps even different from what a will maker thought was fair when preparing their will).

Sometimes outside the box thinking is needed to come up with solutions that meet everyone’s needs rather than resort to the imposition of a concept of fairness that only ends up leaving everyone disappointed.

This is a concept that has unending uses! Although I am yet to experience negotiating with teenagers, I am told that this style of negotiation can work magic. When used well, it can see long-lasting solutions reached in employment contexts, neighbourhood disputes, family law matters and in the “negotiations” we can have every day.

Revisit your values and step into another’s shoes

In my posts about visioning your “new normal”, identifying your values and making good decisions I set out some exercises to help work out your values and goals. If you are about to enter into negotiations with anyone, in any context I would encourage you to revisit those exercises for yourself and to try to put yourself into the shoes of the other person you are about to negotiate with, to image what might be most important to them.

If you are already in legal proceedings, then it is important to communicate with your lawyer about these things. If your lawyer can understand why you want or need something in a settlement, it will make it so much easier to formulate solutions that will work for you and those with whom you are in dispute. It is just as important to explain to your “opposing” party why you are proposing a particular outcome or to say that you are willing to consider other ways to get you to that outcome, because it makes your proposal harder to argue against, and gives the other party (and their lawyer) greater insight into how a win-win settlement might be able to be structured.

In my experience clients rarely have a figure of money or a percentage of the estate in mind for the sake of that figure or percentage, usually it is because they have worked out what they need for their own financial security or because it is what they think is “fair”.

Underlying the wish to “keep the house” for a spouse who might be in a contest with adult step children, is usually the wish to be able to have a home to give them security for the future preferably not far from “the” house so that they can keep as much normalcy as possible.

It is more about what lies beneath the wish, rather than the wish itself.

Roger Fisher’s described a good negotiation like this:

“It should produce a wise agreement if agreement is possible. It should be efficient. And it should improve or at least not damage the relationship between the parties.”

I wholeheartedly agree. I just wish I saw more of it!

fairness, interest based, Negotiation, values

Post navigation

Previous postRenew your mind – smile from the inside out and be kind!
Next postWho do you think you are?

Related Posts

The art of living after loss - making good decisions
The art of living after…
The art of living after loss - a values driven life
The Art of living after…
Bargaining during grief
Bargaining during grief – hope,…

Hello

I am Zinta Harris. I live in Brisbane, Australia with my husband of 25 years, Craig (known by most as Harry) and our two children Teja and Zigi. I am a specialist wills and estates lawyer by day and inspiration seeker by night. I help Australian families navigate the legal fallout after the loss of a loved one in a calm and compassionate way. My mood is better after a daily double shot coffee and a glass or two of bubbles. I get my energy from people. My superpower is encouraging others. It is my sincere hope that this blog will encourage you. I hope it gives you a chance to chime in with your experience or to feel part of a community that has walked through a valley and made it through. Read about me

Check out my new book! “Rest in Peace” – how to manage an estate dispute without inheriting heartache

https://resolveestatelaw.com.au/

Popular posts

Embracing a new season
Embracing a new season
Celebrating Friendship - World Down Syndrome Day
Celebrate Friendships – World Down Syndrome Day 2020!
Sunset over Florence
Italy bucket list trip insider tips – Florence

Follow me on Facebook!

Tags

Acceptance Anger Beauty Bucket list Celebrate Community Direction Family Grief Hope Identity Lifestyle Love Parenting Positive Reality Uncategorized

Insta Inspiration

Veuvey Happy Birthday to me! 🍾🥂🍾 I spent Veuvey Happy Birthday to me! 🍾🥂🍾

I spent the last two days sipping my way through a bottle (or three) of my favourite bubbles @veuveclicquot while spending time with my nearest and dearest! 💕🍾💕

It was a "nothing" birthday. 53... or is it 35? But seeing what I see as an estates lawyer I make sure I mark every one I am blessed to live! 💝💔💝

My heart is so full. I have been showered in love. I have shared so many laughs. I have eaten like a queen and danced like a rock star! I have had so much fun! 💞🤣🍾🥂🦪🕺🍾🥂🤣🤪😍

My amazing hubby sure knows how to spoil me rotten! 😘

Thank you all for your kind messages and calls. I truly feel loved and celebrated! 🥰🎂🥰
.
#happybirthdaytome🎉 #happyplace❤️ #birthdayfestivities #festivalofzinta #foodwineandfriends #familyiseverything❤️ 
#lifeistooshort #celebratinglife #anotherlaparoundthesun
A rare free dress day ahead of the school's cultu A rare free dress day ahead of the school's  cultural night.

I was sad to miss the fun this year to watch Zigi join Teja to represent Latvia! 

But at least Opa and @mara_siksna, Grandma @roslyn.harris.716 and Craig were there to cheer them on! 

#latvian #freedress #culturematters #highschoollife #culturalheritage 
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#lawyersofinstagram #lawyerslife #lawlife #lawinspired 
#lawyering #lifeofalawyer #lawyerswhocare
#mumslife #happymum #happylawyer 
#womeninlaw 
#dowhatyoulovelovewhatyoudo #livecolourfully 
#catchingthecurveball
#resolveestatelaw #brisbanelawyer #brisbanelife #brisbanebusiness
#probate #compassionatelawyer
#choosecompassion #bekindalways
#zintaharris
29 years married to this hunky man I am lucky enou 29 years married to this hunky man I am lucky enough to call my hubby! 💕

We just spent the most amazing 24 hours at @whotels Brisbane! Enjoying a mind-blowing degustation at @bacchusbrisbane last night and an incredible day spa experience at Away spa!🥰

We are so lucky. 💝

We are still in love. We still enjoy adventures together. We still make each other laugh. We still have each other. 😘

We take none of it for granted. 💘

Happy anniversary to us! 💞
.
#happyanniversarymylove #iloveyoualwaysforever
#thosewhoplaytogetherstaytogether
On Friday night I got to hang out with my bestie @ On Friday night I got to hang out with my bestie @tan_hall to see the opening of Aspire at the newly renovated home of the @qldballet at Talbot Theatre West End. 🩰

To watch their talented students perform three unique pieces with stunning interspersed solos was truly breathtaking.

It almost made me want to put my dancing shoes back on...but then I remembered my age (and distinct lack of equivalent talent)!🤣

The future of Qld Ballet is truly in wonderful hands! 🙌
.
#balletlovers #contemporarydance
#supportthearts #brisbaneevents
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#lawyersofinstagram #lawyerslife #lawlife #lawinspired 
#lawyering #attorneys #lifeofalawyer #lawyerswhocare
#womeninlaw #solopreneurs #creativeentrepreneurs
#dowhatyoulovelovewhatyoudo #livecolourfully 
#catchingthecurveball
#resolveestatelaw #brisbanelawyer #brisbanelife #brisbanebusiness
#probate #compassionatelawyer
#choosecompassion #bekindalways
#zintaharris
Happy birthday to my soul mate! AKA the hunky man Happy birthday to my soul mate! AKA the hunky man I get to call my hubby! 💕

We adore you.❤️

You are our world.🌏

We don't know what we did to deserve you.😘

We don't know how we would live without you. 🙃

We love you to the moon and the stars and back! 🌚

Happy 55th birthday you gorgeous man! 🎂

#happybirthdaydad #happybirthdaydad #weloveyoutothemoonandback 
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
#lawyersofinstagram #lawyerslife #lawlife #lawinspired 
#lawyering #attorneys #lifeofalawyer #lawyerswhocare
#mumslife #happymum #creativeentrepreneurs
#dowhatyoulovelovewhatyoudo #livecolourfully 
#catchingthecurveball
#resolveestatelaw #brisbanelawyer #brisbanelife #brisbanebusiness
#probate #compassionatelawyer
#choosecompassion #bekindalways
#zintaharris
One of the hats I get to wear is that of QACP comm One of the hats I get to wear is that of QACP committee member. 

The Queensland Association of Collaborative Professionals was established by a group of Family Law professionals decades ago when the collaborative practice model designed to help divorcing couples separate without going to court - first came to Australian shores. 

After learning about the model, then "stealing" it and tweaking it for Succession Law - I have been on the QACP committee since to help spread the word about how this model can transform the Wills & Estates space!

QACP are kicking off 2023 with a series of FREE "lunch and learn" sessions. The first one will be held at 12pm on 23 May. 

Clarissa Rayward and I will be hosting the first session on how to add Collaborative Practice to your tool kit (for Wills & Estates and Family Law). The session is open to lawyers, financial advisors, psychologists and mediators already working as collaborative professionals or for those interested in learning more about how to get involved!

So - if you have wondered how to offer family inclusive estate planning services to deliver a succession plan that is as watertight as it gets OR if you are yearning for a respectful out-of-court way to resolve estate disputes that eliminates agro and ego - this session will be of interest to you!

The link to register is: https://qacp.org.au/events-and-training/

I hope to see you there!

#collaborativeestates #collaborativelaw #estateplanning #estatelaw #succession #QACP #free
Every estate Law matter is different and your indi Every estate Law matter is different and your individual circumstances will determine what fee structure is best for you. 

We are committed to providing our clients with an open and transparent fee structure that is suitable for them.

Call us to learn more about our fixed-fee probate services on (07) 3371 0795.
Just as the sun emerges from behind the clouds aft Just as the sun emerges from behind the clouds after a rainy day, our lives can also have moments of darkness followed by moments of light and joy.

The sun always comes after the rain, and with each passing storm, we have the opportunity to learn, grow, and appreciate the beauty of life.

#growth #motivationalmonday
Follow on Instagram
  • Facebook
  • instagram
  • linkedin
  • pinterest